In a rare and extraordinary move, families of murder victims, along with Crime Victims United, asked California Supreme Court Associate Justice Kelli Evans to recuse herself from proceedings over Governor Gavin Newsom’s proposed blanket commutation of California’s death sentences, citing her personal role in creating and defending the Governor’s 2019 death penalty moratorium.
In a letter to Chief Justice Patricia Guerrero and the Associate Justices, the signatories ask Justice Evans to step aside from the legal challenge to the proposed commutations and the related Request re Commutation of Death Sentences (S299513, S299690). If she concludes recusal is not warranted, they ask for a public explanation under the California Code of Judicial Ethics. The request is not based on Justice Evans’s views on capital punishment or her appointment by Governor Newsom.
“Our families have spent decades trusting this Court to treat every case fairly. All we are asking for now is that same fairness,” said Marc Klaas, father of Polly Klaas. “Justice Evans helped build the policy the Governor is now relying on. The people deciding this case should be people every Californian can trust to look at it with fresh eyes.”
Justice Evans served in the Governor’s Office from 2019 to 2021 as Deputy and then Chief Deputy Legal Affairs Secretary. The California Supreme Court Historical Society has reported that she played a lead role in crafting and implementing the 2019 moratorium and oversaw the litigation defending it. She also oversaw the Governor’s Parole and Clemency team. On Nov. 9, 2026, the Daily Journal reported that in her application to the Court, Justice Evans identified her role in the moratorium as her proudest accomplishment.
“As an attorney, I know the question here is not whether Justice Evans is actually biased. It is whether a reasonable person who knows the facts would doubt her ability to be impartial,” said Phyllis Loya, former attorney and mother of Pittsburg Police Officer Larry Lasater. “She drafted the executive order that halted carrying out these sentences in the first place, oversaw its defense in court and supervised the Governor’s clemency process. The Code of Judicial Ethics was written for exactly this kind of situation.”
The Governor’s Nov. 5, 2026, letter of intent ties the proposed commutations directly to the 2019 moratorium, and repeats much of the same rationale. Where the moratorium paused these sentences, the commutations would permanently erase hundreds of death sentences, many of which the California Supreme Court has already reviewed and affirmed.
“My son was eight years old,” said Sandy Friend, mother of 8-year-old Michael Lyons. “Our family sat through every step of this process and trusted the system to be fair. We are not asking for any special treatment. We are asking that the Court deciding whether his killer’s sentence stands is one every family can believe in.”
“After my daughter Catina was murdered, I spent decades fighting to make sure victims had a voice in our justice system,” said Harriet Salarno, founder of Crime Victims United and mother of Catina Salarno. “California’s Constitution promises victims fairness, dignity and finality. Recusal takes nothing away from Justice Evans. It protects the credibility of the Court and the families who depend on it.”
The letter notes that Chief Justice Guerrero has emphasized transparency, strong ethical standards and public confidence in the judiciary. The signatories stress that recusal would not diminish Justice Evans’s accomplishments or suggest that her prior service was improper. It would affirm the principle that justice must not only be done, but must be seen to be done.
Read the letter to the California Supreme Court here.

